Get a Quick Quote

Our Service Areas

Independent Insurance Across Tulsa and Beyond

Independent Insurance Across Tulsa and Beyond

Zoellner Insurance is an independent AAA-affiliated agency based in Tulsa, OK. We write auto, home, life, renters, mobile home, and business insurance policies across the Tulsa metro and throughout the state of Oklahoma — shopping AAA, Progressive, Safeco, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Foremost, NatGen, Mercury, and Openly to find you the best rate at every renewal.

We’re not tied to any single carrier. We work for you — comparing the market so you don’t have to, re-shopping your policy automatically at renewal, and providing local claims support from agents who know your policy and your community.

Our primary service area covers the Tulsa metro’s six major suburbs. Each community has its own character, risks, and insurance considerations. Click through to your city below for local pricing data, carrier recommendations, and coverage advice specific to where you live.

→ Not sure if we cover your area? Call (918) 622-7560 and we’ll point you in the right direction.

AAA Insurance
Progressive Insurance
Travelers Insurance
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Safeco Insurance
Foremost Insurance
National General Insurance
Mercury Insurance
Openly Insurance
WS Insurance
Chubb Insurance
Appalachian Underwriters
OGA Insurance
North Star Insurance
AAA Insurance
Progressive Insurance
Travelers Insurance
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Safeco Insurance
Foremost Insurance
National General Insurance
Mercury Insurance
Openly Insurance
WS Insurance
Chubb Insurance
Appalachian Underwriters
OGA Insurance
North Star Insurance

Cities We Serve

Broken Arrow, OK

Population: 127,000+ | County: Tulsa County | ZIP Codes: 74011, 74012, 74014

Broken Arrow is the largest suburb in the Tulsa metro and Oklahoma’s fourth most populous city. With a median household income of $86,765 and a growing residential and commercial base anchored by the Rose District, it’s one of the most economically dynamic insurance markets in the state. High-value homes, heavy commuter traffic on the Creek Turnpike and Broken Arrow Expressway, and flood exposure near Elm Creek make coverage decisions here more complex than in most Oklahoma suburbs. Broken Arrow is also ranked third in manufacturer concentration in Oklahoma — a significant workers’ comp and commercial liability market.

Key coverage considerations: High-value home replacement cost, uninsured motorist coverage on busy expressways, commercial insurance for manufacturing and Rose District businesses, flood policy assessment for Elm Creek corridor properties.

Get A Quote

Owasso, OK

Population: 39,000+ | Counties: Tulsa County / Rogers County | ZIP Code: 74055

Owasso has been one of Oklahoma’s fastest-growing cities for over a decade, with premium residential neighbourhoods — Bailey Ranch, The Fairways, Maple Glen — that have pushed home values and replacement costs well above state averages. The city straddles the Tulsa-Rogers County line, which affects carrier territory ratings for some properties. US-169 is one of the busiest north-south corridors in the metro, and Owasso’s rapid growth means construction and replacement cost benchmarks need annual review to avoid underinsurance.

Key coverage considerations: High-value home extended replacement cost, Rogers County territory rating for border properties, uninsured motorist on US-169, workers’ comp for the growing contractor and healthcare sector.

Get A Quote

Jenks, OK

Population: 26,000+ | County: Tulsa County | ZIP Code: 74037

Jenks is one of Tulsa’s most sought-after southern suburbs — home to the Oklahoma Aquarium, the Riverwalk development, and the Antique District that draws visitors from across the region. Residential growth continues south toward the 121st Street corridor, and the business community is diverse enough to need genuine commercial coverage expertise. Jenks sits close to the Arkansas River, making flood zone assessment relevant for properties near the western edge of the city.

Key coverage considerations: Flood policy assessment for Arkansas River-adjacent properties, business insurance for Antique District retail and Riverwalk hospitality, home and renters coverage for the growing residential base.

Get A Quote

Bixby, OK

Population: 30,000+ | County: Tulsa County | ZIP Code: 74008

Bixby is one of the fastest-growing cities in Tulsa County, with high-value residential development in Gray Oaks, South County, and Charlee Estates that pushes home values above state averages. The city’s position in Tornado Alley, combined with flood exposure along the Arkansas River corridor on the western edge, makes home insurance coverage decisions particularly important. Bixby is served by Union Public Schools — one of the highest-rated school districts in Oklahoma — which supports strong residential demand and continued property value growth.

Key coverage considerations: High-value home replacement cost in Gray Oaks and South County, Arkansas River flood exposure on western properties, auto insurance for Creek Turnpike commuters, commercial coverage for the growing Memorial Drive corridor.

Get A Quote

Sapulpa, OK

Population: 22,000+ | County: Creek County | ZIP Code: 74066

Sapulpa is the seat of Creek County and carries a distinct character — Route 66 heritage, Main Street small businesses, and an industrial base that sets it apart from Tulsa’s bedroom suburbs. Creek County’s insurance market operates differently from Tulsa County, with its own carrier pricing and risk profiles. Sapulpa sits in a hail corridor that sees frequent severe weather, and the combination of older housing stock and commercial diversity makes working with an independent agency — one with access to Creek County-savvy carriers — especially valuable here.

Key coverage considerations: Creek County carrier pricing, hail corridor home insurance, impact-resistant roof discounts, Main Street small business commercial coverage, renters insurance for the rental market.

Get A Quote

Sand Springs, OK

Population: 20,500+ | County: Tulsa / Osage / Creek Counties | ZIP Code: 74063

Sand Springs is unlike any other city in the Tulsa metro — founded in 1911 by philanthropist Charles Page, it grew into an industrial hub anchored by Webco Industries and Sheffield Steel. The city’s older housing stock (median build year: 1980) and its position along the Arkansas River create specific insurance considerations not found in newer suburbs. Sand Springs experienced flooding up to 12 feet in parts of the city in 2019, making flood insurance a genuine necessity for many properties. The February 2026 approval of Project Spring — a Google data center on 827 acres — signals significant new commercial and construction activity through 2029.

Key coverage considerations: NFIP flood insurance for Arkansas River corridor properties, older home coverage for pre-1980 construction, workers’ comp and commercial liability for manufacturing and industrial operations, contractor coverage for the incoming Google data center project.

Get A Quote

We Also Write Insurance Policies Across Oklahoma

Our physical office is in Tulsa, but we write insurance policies statewide. If you live outside the Tulsa metro, we can still quote and service your policy. We’re licensed across Oklahoma and have carrier access that covers the full state.

Communities we regularly serve beyond our primary service area include Glenpool, Collinsville, Skiatook, Claremore, Catoosa, Coweta, and Muskogee.

If your city isn’t listed here, call (918) 622-7560 — if we can write a policy in your area, we will.

Zoellner Insurance is one of the best insurance agencies in Tulsa, OK, with an average client rating of 4.9 on Google

Why Work With an Independent Insurance Agency Across All of Oklahoma?

The insurance market looks different in every Oklahoma community:

  • Creek County rates differ from Tulsa County rates.
  • Rogers County territory definitions affect pricing for some Owasso addresses.
  • Sand Springs’ flood history means NFIP considerations that Owasso residents rarely face.
  • Broken Arrow’s manufacturing concentration creates workers’ comp complexity that a standard home and auto agency isn’t equipped to handle.

 

Working with Zoellner means working with one agency that understands all of these distinctions — not a call centre that treats every Oklahoma ZIP code the same. We match your specific address, property, and situation to the right carrier, rather than applying a one-size-fits-all rate.

  • AAA, Progressive, Safeco, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Foremost, NatGen, Mercury, Openly — nine carriers compared at every renewal
  • Local agents who know the Tulsa metro risk landscape
  • Proactive re-shopping — we don’t wait for you to ask
  • Real claims support — from people who know your policy

 

→ Ready to compare rates? Call (918) 622-7560 or get a free quote online

QUESTIONS ABOUT OUR SERVICE AREAS?

Frequently Asked Questions

No. Our primary service area is Tulsa and its major suburbs — Broken Arrow, Owasso, Jenks, Bixby, Sapulpa, and Sand Springs — but we write policies statewide. If you’re in Oklahoma, call us and we’ll let you know what we can do for your area.No. Our primary service area is Tulsa and its major suburbs — Broken Arrow, Owasso, Jenks, Bixby, Sapulpa, and Sand Springs — but we write policies statewide. If you’re in Oklahoma, call us and we’ll let you know what we can do for your area.

Yes, significantly. Oklahoma insurance carriers price by territory, and the differences between Tulsa County, Creek County, Rogers County, and Osage County can be meaningful. Even within Tulsa County, properties near the Arkansas River, in older neighbourhoods, or in specific hail corridors may attract different pricing than newer suburban construction. We assess your specific address, not just your city.

Absolutely. Many of our clients live in one suburb and operate a business in another. We manage all your policies through a single Zoellner agent regardless of which cities they cover.

Call (918) 622-7560 or use our contact form. We serve communities across Oklahoma and are adding new city-specific pages regularly. If we can write a policy in your area, we will.

That’s exactly why you work with an independent agency. Carrier performance varies by territory — the best carrier for a Broken Arrow homeowner isn’t necessarily the best for a Sapulpa homeowner. We know which carriers perform best in each local market and match you accordingly.

Get Your Free Quote Today!

Call us: (918) 622-7560 | Office: 3702 E 51st Street, Tulsa, OK 74135 | Hours: Monday – Friday, 9am – 5pm | Licensed in:Oklahoma | NPN 18884568

Select your city above for local pricing data and coverage advice, or fill out the quote form below and tell us where you’re located — we’ll take it from there.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name

This site serves residents of the AAA Club Alliance service area which includes Greater Hartford, CT Area, Cincinnati Tri-State Area, Miami County, OH, Greater Dayton, OH Area, Northwest Ohio, AAA Blue Grass & Bluefield Regions, Southern West Virginia, Kansas, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Delaware, Maryland, Washington DC, and parts of Virginia, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. Write Us: AAA Club Alliance, One River Place, Wilmington, DE 19801