Homeowners Insurance in Tulsa, OK

Protecting a home in Tulsa requires more than a generic policy; it requires understanding local risks. From hail season in Tulsa to tornado threats across the state of Oklahoma, Zoellner Insurance Agency knows what it takes to protect your home because we live here too. As an independent agency and your accredited AAA Tulsa agents, we work for you, shopping dozens of top carriers to build custom homeowners insurance policies without breaking your budget.

What is the average cost of home insurance in Tulsa?

In Tulsa, the average homeowners insurance premium is approximately $3,749 annually or $312 per month. For a standard $300,000 home, you can expect to pay around $3,735 to $5,356 per year depending on your choice of carrier and deductible. Newer homes often qualify for lower rates, averaging $1,099 with specific cost-effective insurers.

💡 Expert Tip: In Tulsa, your roof’s age is the biggest price driver. If your roof is over 10 years old, many carriers will only offer Actual Cash Value (ACV) instead of Replacement Cost. We always recommend checking this before storm season hits. You can also learn more about the newly launched OK Ready grant which could help you save on your monthly premiums. 

What Does Homeowners Insurance Actually Cover?

Your policy protects your property and assets through four core components:

Dwelling Coverage

Protects your home’s structure against fire, wind, hail, or vandalism.

Liability Protection

Pays if someone is injured on your property or you cause damage to others.

Additional Living Expenses

Covers temporary housing if your home becomes unlivable after a covered loss.

Other Structures

Protects detached garages, sheds, or fences.

How Can I Reduce My Homeowners Insurance?

With the huge increases the state of Oklahoma as a whole has seen in terms of homeowners insurance premiums, our goals is to save you money. We will do our best the shop you the best rates, but here are some other things you can consider doing for even bigger homeowners insurance discounts:

Bryan Henderson

Zoellner Insurance Client

Tara Evans with Zoellner Insurance AAA was absolutely a pure delight to work with and saved me, not hundreds, but THOUSANDS of dollars on auto and home insurance.

Chuck Zoellner, an AAA independent insurance broker in Tulsa, OK

Feel like you're overpaying? I want to save you money!

My team and I will review your policy and find ways to lower your homeowners insurance premium.

More Homeowners Insurance Discounts

Who has the cheapest home insurance in Tulsa?

To help you find the best value, we have analyzed the average annual premiums for our partner carriers in Tulsa. Rates are based on a standard policy with a $1,000 deductible and varying dwelling coverage limits to match your home’s value.

Note on these rates: These figures represent average estimates for the Tulsa metro area in 2026. Your final premium depends on specific factors like your home’s roof age, your credit-based insurance score, and available bundling discounts.

Carrier

$200k Home

$300k Home

$400k Home

$600k Home

AAA Insurance

$1,280

$1,566

$1,980

$2,740

Progressive

$1,410

$1,718

$2,090

$2,980

Travelers

$2,510

$3,038

$3,620

$4,850

Safeco

$1,520

$1,855

$2,210

$3,120

Mercury

$1,650

$2,120

$2,580

$3,490

Why shop these carriers through Zoellner?

Because we are an independent agency, we aren’t limited to a single company’s pricing. We can run your information through all of these partners simultaneously to see who offers the best “new build” discount or the lowest rate for a historic Midtown home.

  • AAA Insurance: Typically offers the strongest “bundle and save” rewards for existing members.

  • Progressive: Known for highly competitive rates on newly constructed homes in Broken Arrow and Bixby.

  • Safeco: Offers excellent flexibility for homeowners who want to customize their deductible levels.

  • Travelers: A top choice for those needing high-limit coverage for detached structures like workshops or pools.

💡 Expert Tip: In Tulsa, ‘cheap’ isn’t always the goal — you want the lowest rate that doesn’t leave you underinsured when an Oklahoma storm hits. Because we aren’t tied to a single company like State Farm or Allstate, we can shop 20+ carriers to find that exact balance.

Why Choose Zoellner for Homeowners Insurance in Tulsa, OK?

At Zoellner Insurance, we go beyond basic protection — we build a policy around your lifestyle. Here’s why homeowners trust us:

Independent Agency

We shop multiple carriers to secure you the best rates

Local Expertise

We understand Tulsa & surrounding cities unique risks (hail, tornadoes, wind).

Personalized Service

Real people, not call centers or chatbots.

Multi-Policy Savings

Bundle home and auto for extra discounts.

Trusted Guidance

We help you understand your coverage clearly before you buy.

Optional Add-On Coverage Options

Get additional protection with customizable coverage add-ons:

Ask your Zoellner agent which optional coverages fit your property and lifestyle best.

FAQs

Everything You Need to Know About Homeowners Insurance

It covers your home, belongings, liability, and additional living expenses after a covered event like fire, theft, or wind damage.

Yes, most policies cover wind and storm damage from tornadoes — but flood damage is usually excluded unless you add a separate flood policy.

The average Oklahoma homeowner pays $2,000–$2,400 per year, depending on home value, location, and coverage limits. Zoellner Insurance compares quotes to help you save without sacrificing protection.

No — Oklahoma law does not require homeowners insurance, but most mortgage lenders do. If you have a mortgage, your lender will require you to maintain enough coverage to protect the property and their investment. Even if your home is paid off, homeowners insurance is strongly recommended because it protects your house, belongings, and liability from fire, storms, theft, and other unexpected losses. At Zoellner Insurance, we help Oklahoma homeowners choose affordable coverage that fits their home’s value and their comfort level for risk — whether required by a lender or not.

Oklahoma has some of the highest homeowners insurance rates in the U.S., primarily due to the state’s exposure to severe weather — including tornadoes, hail, windstorms, and flooding. The high frequency of storm-related claims drives up repair costs and insurer risk, which increases premiums statewide. Additionally, rising construction and material prices contribute to higher replacement costs for homes. Zoellner Insurance helps offset these expenses by comparing quotes from multiple top-rated carriers and identifying discounts for storm-resistant roofing, security systems, and policy bundles to help homeowners save.

The cost of flood insurance in Oklahoma varies based on your location, property elevation, and flood risk zone. On average, homeowners pay between $700 and $1,200 per year through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). However, rates can be significantly lower for properties outside designated flood zones or when purchased through private carriers. Standard homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so adding a separate flood policy is essential if you live near rivers, creeks, or low-lying areas. Zoellner Insurance can help you determine your flood zone, compare NFIP and private options, and find the most affordable coverage available.

Oklahoma doesn’t sell separate “tornado insurance,” but tornado-related damage is generally covered under a standard homeowners insurance policy as part of your wind and hail coverage. This includes damage from high winds, falling debris, and structural impact caused by tornadoes. However, it’s important to review your deductible, as many insurers in Oklahoma have special wind or storm deductibles that differ from your regular one. Zoellner Insurance works with multiple carriers to ensure your home, roof, and belongings are properly protected from tornado and storm damage at the best possible rate.

Standard homeowners insurance covers many common risks but doesn’t cover everything. Exclusions typically include:

  • Flood damage (requires a separate flood policy)

  • Earthquakes or sinkholes (covered by optional add-ons)

  • Maintenance issues (like mold, rot, or pest infestations)

  • Wear and tear or neglect-related damage

  • High-value items like jewelry or art beyond set limits (unless scheduled)

At Zoellner Insurance, we help you understand exactly what your policy covers — and offer options to fill in gaps with flood, earthquake, or valuables protection, ensuring you have complete peace of mind no matter what happens.

The 80% rule requires you to maintain insurance coverage for at least 80% of your home’s total replacement cost. If your coverage falls below this level, your insurer may not pay the full amount for partial claims. For example, if it costs $300,000 to rebuild your home, you must carry at least $240,000 in dwelling coverage to avoid out-of-pocket penalties after a storm.

Home

HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE: THINGS TO CONSIDER

Homeowners insurance provides financial protection against disasters. A standard policy insures the home itself and the items inside. Homeowners insurance is a package policy. This means that it covers both

Read More »

Our Insurance Carriers

Get a Homeowners Insurance Quote

Protect your home and family with coverage you can trust. Contact Zoellner Insurance Agency today for a free, no-obligation homeowners insurance quote — and let us help you find the right protection for your peace of mind.

This site serves residents of the AAA Club Alliance service area which includes Greater Hartford, CT Area, Cincinnati Tri-State Area, Miami County, OH, Greater Dayton, OH Area, Northwest Ohio, AAA Blue Grass & Bluefield Regions, Southern West Virginia, Kansas, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Delaware, Maryland, Washington DC, and parts of Virginia, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. Write Us: AAA Club Alliance, One River Place, Wilmington, DE 19801

Proudly Serving the Greater Tulsa Community

Serving families in Tulsa, Broken Arrow, Owasso, Bixby, Jenks, Sapulpa, Sand Springs, Glenpool, Collinsville, and Skiatook.